Taste Through Time: NYC's Oldest Eateries Still Serving Since the 1800s

Taste Through Time: NYC’s Oldest Eateries Still Serving Since the 1800s

Within its colorful streets lies a rich tapestry of culinary history: New York City is a bustling metropolis that is recognized worldwide not only as a cultural center but also as a culinary mecca.

Amidst the constantly changing dining environment, a few enterprises have endured and grown into legendary institutions rather than just restaurants.

This article will take you on a historical tour of the restaurants that have been serving food to customers for more than a century. These iconic locations present a live history of New York City, each with an own tale woven into the very fabric of the Big Apple, in addition to a meal.

Come along as we explore the reasons for their enduring popularity and what makes these dining establishments timeless favorites in the middle of the never-ending metropolis.

Fraunces Tavern (est. 1762)

Fraunces Tavern, which opened before the American Revolution, serves as a gateway to colonial America in addition to being a restaurant.

It was once a key gathering spot for the Sons of Liberty and is now a museum and restaurant where guests can enjoy classic American fare paired with a fascinating past.

For those who are interested in American history, it offers a distinctive and engaging dining experience. The menu selections at Fraunces Tavern may not be as extensive or varied as those at contemporary restaurants, nevertheless, for certain patrons.

Delmonico’s (est. 1837)

Since its 1837 opening, Delmonico’s has been known for its superb food and elegant dining, as well as for its private dining rooms and the city’s largest wine cellar.

Taste Through Time: NYC's Oldest Eateries Still Serving Since the 1800s

Delmonico’s is still serving its famous steaks and classic elegance. It is well-known for introducing the globe to delicacies like Baked Alaska and Eggs Benedict.

The Delmonico Steak is, without a doubt, the most highly regarded dish at Delmonico’s. You will be offered a thickly cut, boneless rib-eye that is topped with glazes so that the meat’s natural flavors can shine through.

For individuals who appreciate fine dining and premium meat cuts, this place is a must-visit.

Read More: Slurp Sensation: NYC’s 5 Ultimate Ramen Destinations

Ear Inn (est. 1817)

The Ear Inn has seen numerous transformations over the years, including boarding house and smuggler’s lair. It was once the residence of an African-American hero of the Revolutionary War.

Reminiscent of the early 19th century, Ear Inn delivers a genuine pub experience while preserving its historic beauty. Live music performances are a regular aspect of the bar, which enhances the dining experience with entertainment value.

However, there isn’t much room for dining because Ear Inn is set in a small, old structure. With a variety of house-brewed beers and hearty pub cuisine, it is still the oldest operating tavern in New York City.

Read More: Beefy Bliss: NYC’s Must-Try Steakhouses

Katz’s Delicatessen (est. 1888)

Katz’s is well-known, particularly to those who have gone to the Lower East Side or who have seen it in one of the restaurant’s numerous film and television appearances. Pastrami sandwiches from Katz’s Delicatessen are famous for being as tall as the city’s skyscrapers.

Taste Through Time: NYC's Oldest Eateries Still Serving Since the 1800s

With each bite, this kosher-style deli offers a sense of Jewish-American tradition, making it a favorite among both New Yorkers and tourists.

The Iceland brothers founded the Jewish deli and cafe in 1888. Later, they merged with the Katz family to form Iceland and Katz.

Read More: Time-Tested Icons: NYC’s 5 Oldest Buildings and Their Enduring Stories

Keens Steakhouse (est. 1885)

Keens Steakhouse, once the meeting place for the most powerful people in the city, is still a shining example of classic New York dining. Renowned for its dry-aged steaks and mutton chops, Keens provides a flavorful and historically rich dining experience.

As it has been serving delicious steaks since 1885, this historic restaurant remains one of the best spots in the city to savor a juicy cut of meat. Keens is a museum dedicated to the history of New York, not just a steakhouse.

Keens is well-known for its enormous, tender, and flavorful mutton chops. Additionally, a selection of steaks, including filet mignon, porterhouse, and sirloin, are available.

Read More: Sunset Strolls: 5 Top Sunset Viewing Spots in NYC

To Conclude

Entering these storied eateries in New York City is akin to traveling back in time. They provide more than simply a meal; they also provide a window into the rich history of the area and a taste of the culinary customs that have helped to create the dynamic metropolis that is today’s Big Apple.

So make sure to visit one of these classic New York establishments the next time you’re craving a bit of the past.