Social Security Eligibility: Can Illegal Immigrants Claim Social Security Benefits?

Social Security Eligibility: Can Illegal Immigrants Claim Social Security Benefits?
Image Via: Education Week

There are many different sides to the controversial and complex question of whether illegal immigrants should be eligible for Social Security benefits. It discusses aspects of law, economics, and ethics, each with its own set of issues and ramifications.

On June 27, 2024, the current president and the previous president engaged in heated dispute on a variety of topics, including immigration law.

During the discussion, the outgoing president made the claim that the present administration is allowing individuals who are in the country illegally to get Medicare and Social Security benefits.

Legal Viewpoint of this Controversial Question

Undocumented immigrants are legally ineligible to receive Social Security payments. To be eligible for benefits, a person must have paid into the Social Security system through payroll taxes and have a valid Social Security number, according to the Social Security Administration (SSA).

Since illegal immigrants do not have legal authority to work in the U.S., they are not issued Social Security numbers and, thus, cannot legally receive Social Security payments.

Economic Consequences

Those who support giving illegal immigrants Social Security benefits contend that a large percentage of undocumented workers pay payroll taxes into the system by using fictitious or borrowed Social Security numbers.

The Social Security Administration claims that these unclaimed donations support the Social Security trust fund. It might be argued that granting undocumented workers benefits is justified because estimates place their yearly contributions into the billions of dollars.

However, some contend that adding illegal immigrants to the list of recipients of Social Security payments will add to the already burdensome financial load on the system.

They claim that the principal goal of Social Security is to benefit citizens and legal residents who have contributed to the system during their working life.

What You Need To Know: 

Moral Aspects to Take into Consideration

The concepts of justice and fairness are at the heart of the ethical discussion. The humanitarian argument is frequently used by proponents of granting benefits to illegal immigrants, who point out that many of these individuals have been in the country for a long time and have made significant contributions to the community and economy.

They contend that it is unfair and cruel to deny them benefits, particularly because they have contributed to the system. On the other hand, detractors argue that giving Social Security benefits to undocumented immigrants compromises legal order and may encourage undocumented immigration.

They contend that benefits ought to be restricted to people who have obtained citizenship and residency through legitimate means.

Medicare and Social Security benefits are not available to undocumented immigrants

According to Julia Gelatt, associate director of the U.S. Immigration Policy Program at the Migration Policy Institute, certain noncitizens may be eligible for these benefits, but they must be legally residing in the country and fulfill additional qualifying requirements.

According to the Congressional Research Service (CRS), undocumented immigrants, often known as undocumented immigrants, “are not eligible for most federal benefits,” with a few exceptions for items like emergency Medicaid.

However, ordinary Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid benefits are not covered by those exclusions.

  • According to the nonprofit health policy organization KFF, undocumented immigrants are also not able to enroll in government supported health coverage, such as Medicaid or Medicare.
  • Medicare offers federal health insurance to qualified individuals 65 years of age and older, as well as those individuals under 65 with specific medical conditions or impairments.
  • According to the National Immigration Forum, although some states may offer health benefits to undocumented immigrants, the majority of this population does not have any health coverage outside of emergency treatment.

Final Thoughts

The issue of whether or not undocumented immigrants should be eligible for Social Security payments is intricate and multidimensional. Despite strong arguments on both sides, unauthorized immigrants are not eligible for these benefits under the current legal system.

It would take considerable legislative effort and rigorous analysis of the ethical, legal, and economic ramifications to change this policy.

The Sources:

No, undocumented immigrants aren’t eligible for Social Security and Medicare

Fact Check: Are Immigrants Getting Social Security?

profile
With more than two years of expertise in news and analysis, Eileen Stewart is a seasoned reporter. Eileen is a respected voice in this field, well-known for her sharp reporting and insightful analysis. Her writing covers a wide range of subjects, from politics to culture and more.